Planting hope

Amid the wreckage of MH17 and a war, Fairfax chief correspondent Paul McGeough and photographer Kate Geraghty decided to collect a keepsake for family and friends of the victims.

Yeah, Nicola, pull the other one.

The last time we had come up against Canberra in our work we were in Afghanistan, and Australian foreign affairs and defence officials had orchestrated a determined campaign to block us reporting independently from Oruzgan province – and on failing, had wheeled in the men of the Australian Defence Force to arrest us.

Now, this woman who identified herself as Nicola Hinder was texting me out of the blue.

It was Christmas week 2014 and I was chilling at Carrickmacross, a small farm in the Rappahannock Valley, west of Washington, to which we retreat when the world gets too loud or violent. Hinder was at Dora Creek, near Lake Macquarie on the NSW coast, where she had been dangling a line from the boardwalk when a news feed she was reading on her mobile phone snapped her to attention.

Hinder was interrupting her Christmas reverie to interrupt my Christmas reverie because, as she put it, ‘‘alarm bells went off’’ as she read of our plan to distribute sunflower seeds from the MH17 crash site in war-torn eastern Ukraine to the families and friends of the 38 crash victims from Australia.

What we saw as a humane gesture, she saw as a dire challenge to Australia’s strict quarantine protection regime.

We – photographer Kate Geraghty and myself – had been flying blind and we still were. Nearing the end of almost a month reporting on a mindless Ukrainian separatist war and the heart-numbing missile strike that destroyed the Malaysia Airlines Boeing 777 on July 17, 2014, we had decided that if families and friends of the Australian victims could not get to the crash site, then we were obliged to bring them a keepsake.

First we wondered about a small quantity of soil, which might be carried in a locket. But we settled on seeds – they would be lighter, more compact and, with careful gardening, might be propagated from year to year. It would help too, we thought, that sunflowers are such happy chaps.

We were an Australian news crew in a war zone. However, because we were not there in any official capacity, it seemed we alone had the freedom of movement to harvest the seeds. But as time ran out and my imagination took over, we became overwhelmed by the idea.

“This is something for government,” I told Geraghty, and then I contacted Prime Minister Tony Abbott’s office to outline my grand plan, which was for Canberra to buy a local farmer’s crop of sunflower seed and distribute the seeds to families and friends of Australian victims and perhaps even to governments representing the other 260 victims. But there was no call back from Canberra – and the appearance of giant harvesters in nearby fields told us we needed to act fast.

We made a dawn arrival at Rassypnoe, which we had dubbed ‘‘the cockpit village’’ because it was where the cockpit section of MH17 had crashed to earth. We stood among head-high plants with a big empty suitcase – and in the absence of any cutting tool, we soon found that the only way to part the bread-plate sized flowers from the stringy stems was to wring their necks, as it were. We then drove north for five hours, to clear the conflict zone, and flew to Kiev.

In the capital, my hotel room quickly took on the look and smell of a barnyard, as I shucked the seeds from the flower heads. By 2 o'clock the next morning my hands were blistered and blackened, but the volume of the bulky suitcase had shrunk to a more manageable bundle of tightly rolled hotel laundry bags, weighing just 1.5 kilograms. Geraghty headed to Australia that morning; I came home to the US.

Thomas Schansman, from the Netherlands, tells of the pain of losing his son Quinn, who was killed on MH17:

I sat on the seeds for some months, uncertain of how or when to intrude on what was unbearable grief for so many after mass murder above the fields of eastern Ukraine, of the fathers and mothers, uncles and aunts, siblings and cousins and friends who they had known so intimately.

Christmas week seemed right. It would be the first time since the crash for many of the families and friends to gather and the absence of the victims was sure to be painfully felt.

Small as it was, perhaps our offer of sunflower seeds might bring a little solace.

I wrote a piece inviting people to contact me if they wanted seeds as a regenerative garden memorial to their lost ones. That’s what Nicola Hinder was reading on the boardwalk at Dora Creek. “I am with the Australian Department of Agriculture,” she said in a text, which I received on December 27. “I would very much like to talk to you about your SMH article regarding the seeds from the Ukraine. I would like to work with you on this issue – and need to discuss.”

Need to discuss? Now it was my turn to hear alarm bells. Invariably, such words from Canberra meant obfuscation and obstruction. At the same time, I understood that our choices were limited – we’d probably have to work with this Nicola. I texted back: “I always figured there’d be a quarantine issue, but that if I pressed ahead, it would come to me. Happy to call you…”

And so began a relationship in which, for a long time, I did Hinder the great disservice of allowing my ingrained suspicions of all things Canberra to blind me to the reality that she was a good and genuine human being. For me, the difficulty was her insistence on taking control of the seeds in Australia.

If we were to get them into the country, we’d have to accept her undertaking that she would deploy her colleagues to use our seeds to grow a batch of sunflower plants in a secure quarantine facility; to harvest them and, if that second generation of seeds was found to be free of pests and disease, it would be given to us to distribute to the MH17 families and friends.

Hinder arranged for me to drop the seeds at the Australian embassy in DC, to be dispatched to her in the diplomatic mail.
By then I had dried and repacked them in three bags, of about 500 grams each. Now, as I drove up to the white-grilled facade on Massachusetts Avenue on a chilly January morning, a voice in the back of my head insisted that I hold back one bag, just in case whatever I surrendered to Hinder’s diplomatic colleagues was ‘‘disappeared’’.

When Hinder started talking in her emails about the ‘‘viability’’ of the seeds I was again suspicious and decided to do my own ‘‘viability’’ test. I sprouted a few seeds in damp cotton wool in a saucer on my kitchen windowsill – and tweeted a picture of the first tender shoots. “Proof of life,” I told Geraghty.

Hinder then broke the news to me that on being examined by her expert colleagues, the seeds were found to be of poor quality. And when she speculated on a fallback, of setting some of the seeds in resin blocks to give to the families and friends, I thought: “Uh, uh – we didn’t do all this to give the families and friends a paperweight.”

The offer of seeds from the fields over which MH17 had disintegrated elicited a heartfelt response from across Australia and around the world. First there were dozens and then a steady trickle till as recently as June 2015, from the families and/or friends of all the Australian victims and from victim families in the Netherlands, Britain, Italy, Indonesia, Malaysia and elsewhere.
The Dutch father of the only American on the flight wanted seeds. The family of the sole New Zealander asked for some, as did the Melbourne-based brother of Captain Eugene Choo, one of the pilots on the MH17 service that was bound for Kuala Lumpur from Amsterdam.

“My wife, Catherine, lost a friend in the MH17 disaster and I would like to surprise her…”

Dan Talbot, in Busselton, WA

Even the emails I received in which the authors had tried to withhold information told me something – like the extended family for whom the MH17 grief was infinitely more complex, because of another deep turmoil that was only alluded to; and from a woman, the hint of an affair or perhaps unrequited love in a brief email in which she did not reveal the name of the man for whom she mourned – and who she wished to remember with sunflowers in her garden.

Their collective grief pummelled me like an ocean dumper.
Meryn and Jon O’Brien, in Old Toongabbie, NSW, were mourning their son: “Our son Jack O’Brien, 25 years old, was killed on board flight MH17…”

Janine Kaye, in Karrinyup, Western Australia, was guiding her pre-teen daughter through the cruel and abrupt end to a friendship: “My daughter Lucy is 11 and Evie Maslin [one of three siblings from WA who died in the crash with their grandfather] was one of her closest school friends. Her heartbreak over Evie’s loss is an ongoing struggle…”

Dan Talbot, in Busselton, WA, wanted to console his bereft wife:
“My wife, Catherine, lost a friend in the MH17 disaster and I would like to surprise her…”

Jonn Ayley, in Tawa, NZ, was blunt on his family’s loss: “Our son Robert was blown to pieces by the missile…”

Vanessa Rizk, in Sunbury, Victoria, was resigned to becoming an orphan: “It’s just my brother and myself now. We have some amazing extended family – but nothing is going to compare to our beloved parents.”

Sam Nord-White, in Mount Eliza, Victoria, looked out from the gaping hole left in her family by the death of her sister Frankie and her brother-in-law Liam Davison, but she couldn’t touch the sides:
“We’re still in disbelief that they’re not coming home from their holiday.”

“People say it gets easier every day, but it hasn’t started yet for any of us.”

Sam Nord-White

Still in Mount Eliza, Kerry Saville was also mourning the Davison couple who for her, were dear friends: “I was struck by the strange beauty of the fields of sunflowers. I clung to the thought that amidst the horror we watched and felt was a strange beauty that our friends would have somehow appreciated. The sunflower has become a comforting symbol amongst family and friends and I would love to have some seeds if you have enough.”

Clearly, in the face of such outpourings a paperweight would not cut it. But I worried for naught – Nicola Hinder would come through for them all.

ABOVE Mark Whattam (left) shows the sunflower seeds to Darryl Barbour (centre) and Nicola Hinder (right), all from the Department of Agriculture.

Hinder, 43, is assistant secretary for pathway compliance at the Department of Agriculture, which puts her in charge of what we used to call quarantine – these days it’s called biosecurity. That obscure title of hers is about ensuring adherence to Australia’s strict regulations on the import of all plants and animals, under which sunflower seeds are deemed a high risk. Hinder was already alive to the Ukraine story by dint of her membership of an interdepartmental committee managing the MH17 crisis in Canberra.

As one of her colleagues put it, she could have thrown the book at us. Instead, as others articulated regulatory protocols on the importation of dodgy seeds, Hinder went in to bat for us.

“Initially, there was quite a debate – but it was Nicola who prosecuted the argument that we should do the right and decent thing,” the colleague said.

Without that backing and the science that Hinder and her colleagues brought to the venture, even if we did get the seeds into the country, they likely would have been a disappointment to any gardener.

Hinder reported back regularly. Initially it seemed the only good news was from the saucer on my kitchen windowsill. Her reports from expert colleagues at the Knoxfield Post Entry Quarantine Facility in Melbourne’s south-east were dispiriting – externally, the seeds were very dry, of poor quality; internally, they were poorly developed and shrivelled.

But because of what was happening at my kitchen window, she added: “I have asked the guys to sow a bunch of the seeds and we will know in about seven days, if there are any signs of growth.”
Hinder spared me some of the grim detail. But recently her plant pathologist colleague Mark Whattam revealed to me just how precariously our venture had been poised.

“First, we tried to germinate some of the seeds on cotton wool – but no success,” he said. Next he opted for a hot water treatment. “We kept them in water at 52C for 20 minutes, to sterilise the outside and some of the inside of the seeds,” he said. “Of 1000 to 2000 seeds treated, just 40 to 50 germinated.”

The best of the seedlings were then potted separately in 20 pots, which were divided into two lots and placed in separate glasshouses – “we split them just in case something went wrong in one of the glasshouses,” Whattam explained.

On January 28, there was a mood swing in Hinder’s reporting:

“I am pleased to let you know that there is cautious optimism from our end.”

Doing the maths, she reckoned that on a typical yield of about 1000 seeds per sunflower head, the 20 plants would give us about 20,000 seeds – “a larger number than you brought back”.

It was time to let go of my doubts about Hinder’s good intentions, and in a January 29 email, I told her: ‘‘I need to thank you and your colleagues for such a decent, human and sporting response.’’

We all had to bide our time for about 20 weeks as the plants matured, during which Hinder sent a running series of photographic reports – the first of which showed two tiny green leaves bravely pushing through a cover of mulch, with a 10¢ coin beside them for us to gauge how big – or perhaps how small – they were.

Meanwhile, Whattam and his colleagues did regular examinations to ensure our seeds would not introduce any exotic diseases to Australia.

By the start of March, the plants were about 60 centimetres tall. “Hopefully we’ll see the development of some seed heads within the next few weeks,” Hinder said.

On March 25 she reported the plants had reached 1 to 1.5 metres in height – and seed heads were developing. But as the flower heads formed, Whattam turned his mind to a particular problem – how to cross-pollinate them in the absence of bees. His solution was to get one of the taller members of his staff to go from one plant to the next with a paintbrush, brushing the pollen from plant to plant.

By mid-May the flowers were drying off and the leaves seemed to be dying too – all good news, because it meant all the plants’ starch and nutrients were being directed into healthy seeds.

The last of my suspicions had withered and died too and Hinder was my new best friend – did I tell you that she works for the government? Now we were commiserating each other on the challenges of family life – at the end of April she was off on an 11-hour drive, to a place she described as ‘‘far inland Queensland’’, to collect her father for his 80th birthday; early in May, I had to travel to Perth to bury my 91-year-old mother.

On May 8 she wrote: “Good evening Paul – excellent news! I’m pleased to report that the seed is being actively harvested … to allow them to dry out properly it has been necessary to remove the flower heads [from the plants] and move them into our office…”

And on May 20, this: “Our plant pathologists sorted the best seeds from those grown, so that we can be reasonably sure of having healthy plants come from the [new] seed stock … ”

I had been slow on the uptake. Now I better understood the talk of seed quality and viability – at a paltry 4 or 5 per cent, the germination rate of the seeds we collected in the cockpit village risked being barren for the families and friends of the MH17 victims.

But incrementally, Hinder’s emails had revealed an amazing win-win operation, in which she and Whattam insisted they complied with all the regulations. But it was as though these two had willed our dodgy batch of seeds to deliver a healthy second-generation crop, all plump and shiny, which they estimate has a likely germination rate of 80 to 90 per cent. And for us, they did it gratis, waiving fees of as much as $10,000 that would have been levied on any commercial importer.

And there’s more – Hinder’s idea of setting some of the seeds in resin proved to be the preferred choice of dozens who had asked for seeds.

As we packed the last of about 200 packets of seeds and resin blocks late in June, to be dispatched across Australia, I began receiving emails and letters from MH17 families in Europe, to whom we had been able to send seeds months earlier, because the continental biosecurity regimes are far less restrictive than in Australia.

An email from Hans de Borst, in the Dutch seaside town of Monster, was an explosion of colour – a burst of delicate yellow by his garden fence, which he described as ‘‘new life’’, a reference to his 17-year-old daughter Elsemiek who died in the crash, along with her mother, her stepfather and half-brother.

Days later, a Dutch TV crew brought me a video clip of 55-year-old Thomas Schansman, whose son Quinn died as he travelled to Indonesia to meet his family for a holiday. Showing the cameraman a thriving sunflower plant, Schansman says: “We treat it … well, we treat it like a baby, our baby Quinn.”

Geraghty and I had set a target of getting the seeds to families and friends before the July 17 anniversary of the MH17 tragedy. In the first week of July, we dispatched parcels and resin blocks to families around the country.

Here at Carrickmacross, in Virginia’s rolling Rappahannock County, we nestle at the back end of a quiet little valley, where we share a boundary, some black bears and the odd glass of rye with Mac, a former security agencies type, who calls me ‘‘pardner’’.

This whole remarkable sunflower venture, this incredible journey with and into the lives of people who never expected to be hurled front and centre into the grief and grind that is the news of the day, could not have happened without mine and Geraghty’s new pardner – Nicola Hinder. I’m ashamed I ever doubted her.
As Mac might say to her:

“Thanks, pardner – we couldn’t have done it without you.”

SUPPLIED IMAGES Department of Agriculture VIDEO Kate Geraghty, Een Vandaag, AVRO/TROS Dutch Television VIDEO EDITING Stephen Claxton PRODUCTION/DESIGN Mark Stehle MULTIMEDIA EDITOR Felicity Lewis